Marmi di Carrara, since 1956
Get a quote

Guides · Marmi di Carrara · 1956

Marble or granite for kitchen countertops and floors?

Updated · By Marmi di Carrara srl

Durability and strength: two rocks, two hardnesses

Granite is an igneous rock made of quartz, feldspars and micas, with a Mohs hardness between 6 and 7: a knife does not scratch it, nor does sand under shoes. Marble is a metamorphic rock of calcium carbonate, hardness 3-4: it works and polishes beautifully, but a blade scratches it and it wears a little in the passages of a floor. Granite is also less porous, although many light granites are resin-treated at the factory to close micropores. Neither breaks in normal use: a 3 cm top, in marble or granite, lasts decades. The difference lies in the surface, not in the structure.

Care: how much each one asks

Granite is cleaned with water and a neutral detergent and, if not resin-treated, a protective treatment every few years is more than enough. Marble is cleaned the same way, with a pH-neutral cleaner and a microfibre cloth, but the protective treatment must be renewed every one or two years, because the stone absorbs more and does not tolerate acids. For both, limescale removers and harsh detergents should be avoided: on granite they do no visible harm, on marble they do. Those who choose marble in a kitchen learn to wipe lemon, wine and vinegar straight away and usually prefer a honed finish, which hides small marks.

Heat and scratches: where granite is unbeatable

On heat both are stones and take a hot pan well, although we always recommend a trivet to avoid thermal shock near cut-outs and joints. On scratches granite wins clearly: its hardness makes it almost indifferent to knives, pots and sand. On acids the gap is even wider: granite is siliceous and does not react with lemon, vinegar or tomato; marble is calcareous and reacts, leaving a dull halo that shows immediately on a polished surface. This is the honest reason why, around the hob and sink, granite has the easier life.

Value over time: patina and character

A granite top stays almost identical for decades: a practical virtue, but also an aesthetic limit, because granites come in dark or speckled colours and rarely in the luminous white that contemporary projects look for. Marble changes: it dulls, picks up some marks, and that patina is part of its charm; when it is no longer wanted, it is re-honed and re-polished on site and comes back as new. Both are unique pieces of mountain, but in the perceived value of a home the white marbles of Carrara, Statuario and Calacatta have a recognition few granites reach, and that shows when the house is sold.

Sustainability: two stones, two origins

Marble and granite are both a single material, with no resin in their body, repairable, reusable and still stone at the end of their life. Granite, however, almost always comes from far away: our granites are imported directly and worked in our own workshops, and the journey weighs on the environmental balance; many light granites also receive a resin treatment at the factory. Our white marbles come from our own quarries above Carrara, a few kilometres from the workshops. We want to be fair: quarrying marble has a cost too, and a granite that lasts thirty years with no care is itself a sensible choice. Distance, though, makes a difference.

When to choose one or the other

Choose granite for the hob and sink area, for an outdoor or high-traffic floor, for steps and thresholds, and in general when you want a stone that asks nothing and you accept dark or speckled colours. Choose marble for the island, the breakfast bar, the bathroom, walls, an elegant indoor floor, and whenever the project calls for white, veins and light. Many kitchens combine the two: granite at the hob, marble on the island, with the same thickness and the same edge. Our warehouse holds slabs in 2, 3 and 4 cm, polished or honed; other finishes are on request.

Frequently asked questions

Is granite really tougher than marble in a kitchen?
Yes, clearly: it is harder, knives do not scratch it and it does not react with lemon, vinegar or tomato. Marble takes heat just as well, but acids mark it and it scratches more easily.
Are there white granites like marble?
There are light granites, but they have a speckled grain and rarely the even white with veins sought in Calacatta or Statuario. If the project calls for a luminous white, the answer is almost always marble.
Can I see the real slabs before deciding?
Yes. Marble and granite slabs are in stock in Carrara, with photos of each lot online. You can visit the showroom or book a video call and look at them with us, slab by slab.
Can marble and granite be combined in the same kitchen?
Yes, it is a frequent solution: granite around the hob and sink, marble on the island or breakfast bar. With the same thickness and edge profile the two materials match well.
What thickness do you suggest for a granite or marble top?
For kitchens usually 3 cm, for floors and cladding 2 cm. Our warehouse holds slabs in 2, 3 and 4 cm, polished or honed; other finishes on request.

See also

Request a quote

WhatsApp